Perfect, so a £5.5k difference on that before the grant, which could arguably come down if paperwork requirements were less … great example
I’ve added your systems @simon_sh @Rachel @gm0705 @steveconuk but not sure of all the values to complete the entries. @steveconuk what do you think is your SCOP and annual electric consumption?
heatpump_costs2.ods (26.7 KB)
It would be interesting to get more examples of boiler vs heat pump costings, both boiler replacements and costs for installation of new boiler systems including radiators and pipework.
1 Like
Daikin 4 KW system.
Hopefully the information below is the information you require.
SPF based on MMI 3.65
Elec for Heating and Hot water 1151 kWh
Heat required based on survey data 4202
This is my first winter with the system, I am still learning the ropes.
1 Like
My rental properties all have modem radators as CH heating installed within last 20 years, my home is likely 40 year old radiators/pipes. So when gas boiler in rentals need replacing it can be a simple like-for-like swap done with one day labour, likely pipes will need no changes if keep to same make.
Radators in my home will be replaced when removed to do other work if not allready replaced for other reason.
FWIW, there’s an article at Heat Pump SCOPs – The Truth Might Not Be What You Think - Renewable Heating Hub based on data from https://heatpumpmonitor.org/
2 Likes
Disagree about the alternative DHW mechanisms (solar PV etc), its just skewing the stats rather than enhancing the HP.
Economically it doesn’t make much sense either for SEG users, 15p export and overnight 7.5-12p divided by 2.5 COP is cheaper than diverting during the day etc.
The lack of ground source representation in the top 20 is err a lack of ground source representation in general 
3 Likes
Hey
I think you might consider calculating the Levelised Cost of Energy (in this case for heat).
This is comparable to gas/oil etc.
It’s the metric that professionals would use when comparing electricity generation costs between technologies.
I’ll reach out to Lewis - happy to show you how to add it to the spreadsheet. Likewise if you want some help adding to some of your open source code let me know.
Then you’ll need to depreciate assets at different rates - one assumes a heatpump has a shorter shelf life than new oversized radiators for example.
I’m working on doing these calculations using 80 years of hourly weather data in an upcoming app. That’s beyond the scope of a spreadsheet or PHP but will cointegrate with solar simulation.
Best
Ben
1 Like
Thanks @kilowatts.io, it would be great to have your input on improving the calculation model, cheers!
Air Source Heat Pump direct replacement for oil central heating boiler - the payback can be very different…
This year I replaced my 25 year old oil fired central heating boiler with a Samsung 8kW Mono HT Quiet as a direct replacement reusing all the existing plumbing and tanks. I would be interested to know if anyone else has tried it. Running at slightly higher temperatures may be less efficient but it is still be much lower cost than heating oil. I found the low cost, ease of installation and the much reduced disruption made up for the loss of the boiler upgrade scheme.
The house is a 4 bedroom detached brick built in an exposed location in the south of England dating from 1890 with a modern extension. It is fully double glazed with loft insulation to around 300mm and cavity wall filled in the extension only. I would need to upgrade wall insulation for a BUS grant unless I could argue the old building is not suitable. The MCS certified quotes wanted to replace the DHW tank with a plant room and all new pipework to give the guarantee and the quotes started at £15k.
To test the suitability of my heating last winter I set my 18kW Wallstar boiler to 48C flow temperature. Set like this the daily fuel use on the coldest day was 12 litres. The 25 year old oil burner never quite reached the 18C house target temperature in all rooms on sub zero days but it was comfortable enough with the log burner when really cold. I was using 1500 litres of heating oil a year at a cost of £1200 at 80p/litre. From this trial I calculated the peak heat loss.
The replacement ASHP reused the existing indirect DHW cylinder and all the pipe work reducing costs and labour. I made no changes to the radiators except to fit fans to two radiators in the kitchen and living room. I did not fit a buffer tank. A Samsung approved speed controlled Grundfos pump was fitted in place of the old one. All the existing pipe work is 15mm minimum with 28mm to the DHW tank and whilst old it is all still in a good serviceable condition.
The Samsung supplied controller was wired up and set to use the LCD wired room thermostat with water law settings 15c,-5c : 35c,48c. All other settings are as factory. The consumer unit wiring needs to be completed and checked by an electrician. The header tank was flushed, filled and checked for leaks. The system was then switched on to test. After few minutes the new Grundfos pump started, the controller booted up and the heat pump started working first time with no fault messages.
The first test was to select DHW and it reached a 60 degree flow temperature in about ten minutes and heated the existing tank to a 45 deg C in 60 minutes. The COP based on the display was 2.4 so cheaper than heating oil when using Octopus Cosy tariff.
I opened all the thermostatic radiator valves and zones and found that with a flow temperature of 38C it keeps the whole house at 19 deg C with typical outside temperatures of 10 deg C. The COP is estimated at around 4.
I had to wait for freezing days in November for a real test. Temperatures were below zero all day with snow on the ground, and the heat pump performing the defrost cycles every hour or so. The flow temperature rises to 48deg and all rooms were achieving 18C. It is clear that you must run the ASHP continuously for this comfort level. I never turn it off but there is a set back temperature at night. Comparing oil of 12 litres a day maximum for the space heating and DHW I now use 40kWh and the COP is 2.5, at my average unit cost of 18p the daily cost is £7.20 compared with £9.60 for oil on the coldest days, i.e 25% cheaper. The comparable running costs will be even better on milder days due to the improved COP.
I found it was an easy job for anyone with plumbing knowledge but it does, of course, require a qualified electrician to complete the wiring. The official manuals are rather over detailed and difficult to understand but Midsummer Energy Ltd supplies everything you need and has a good summary of how to install this type of heat pump. Any qualified plumber could do this work. I notified the DNO on line after installation and there was no problem getting the approval to connect. In my case no planning consent was required provided I followed the local planning guidelines and building regulations.
Manufacturer’s guarantee may be affected if you do it yourself, of course. I registered for the extended warranty with Samsung on line as there may still be some recourse if a manufacturing defect is found at a later date. Samsung UK will respond if you need help with their products.
There are 1.5 million homes with oil fired central heating in the UK. If the pipework is serviceable with an indirect DHW tank then they could benefit from ASHP without needing to replace the internal plumbing systems. For my simple installation example the additional costs of ASHP compared to a replacement oil boiler can be expected have a payback of less than ten years even without the BUS scheme and MCS certification.
6 Likes
Thanks for a great write up. Whats the dt between flow/return when heatpump working hard?
Two thoughts.
What about a basic A2A in the living room to use when very cold?
If the money saved on radiators was spend on a home battery (eg one or two Fogstar 15kw) and a tariff with a low overnight rate used, what would running costs be?
1 Like
Glad you found it interesting. I do not have reliable return temperatures readings but will check it out when I fit some monitoring. I will likely increase the size of radiators to improve efficiency in the future but right now it works OK.
I have a log burner to use when it is very cold in the living room so that works for me but A2A is always an option.
Interesting you mention batteries because I already have 7.2kWh of battery storage as part of my solar installation. I do use these batteries to make full use of the off peak tariff, two full charge/discharge cycles a day on cosy Octopus is worth around a £1.40 a day to me so it is definitely worth doing.
2 Likes
Apologies for very late set of info!
My HP install was done under the HeatGeek assured scheme, with design consultation in Feb 2024, installation June and commissioning July. Previously had gas combi, which for the period July-December 2023 was already running mostly at 50°C flow temperature with 3rd party controls and weather compensation. For some of the time heating on 24/7 with an overnight setback. It was a period of tinkering.
Design consultation: £350 (inc VAT)
Heat Geek guarantee: £500 (this was reduced from a higher figure due to problems with the website and Heat Geek design tools which I reported)
Parts:
- Heat pump: 7Kw Vaillant Arotherm+ £3806
- HP accessories, sundries, electrical parts (inc new consumer unit) £2635
- Controls: Vaillant sensoCOMFORT (Wireless Controls) plus gateway £435
- Cylinder: Vaillant uniSTOR 200L £1014
- Radiators (5) and valves (12) £1188
Parts Total £9079 (no VAT payable)
Labour:
- General, including moving around an additional 4 radiators £5656
- Heat Pump Monitoring Level 3 £300
Labour Total £5956 (no VAT payable)
Additional work post installation - plastic pipework replaced with copper (parts and labour) £655 inc VAT
Level 3 Heat Pump Monitoring Bundle £942 inc VAT
Grand Total to date £10132
Target temperature of 18°C.
Heat Geek Estimated system efficiency: 380% efficiency at 45°C max flow temperature
HOUSE LOSS 7.99kW
ROOMS 11 Total
EXT. TEMP. -3.0°C
The heat pump has been installed and running for 6 months. Early heat metering errors appeared to have disppeared, but some more reported recently (only thing that’s changed is defrost cycles…)
Heat losses were calculated on the assumption that underfloor insulation would be installed - it still hasn’t happened, and ground floor less well insulated than a year ago!
Heat loss for loft bedroom greater than modelled, and waiting for an even bigger radiator (will have to pay for radiator, but not labour).
Heatpumpmonitor space heating stats for July to December:
- Electricity: 1593 kWh
- Heat: 6995 kWh
- Mean Flow temp: 29.4°C
- Heating COP: 4.19
- Mean Outside temp: 8.6°C
- Mean Inside temp (first floor N facing bedroom): 19.6°C
I switched from the Octopus flexible tariff @ 22p/kWh for electricity to Agile in mid September (I also had the gas meter removed around the same time)
I’ve quickly checked Octopus bills (last 3 weeks of December 2024 from Octopus Compare). Combined gas and electricity costs for July-December 2023 appear to be £690 (tracker for gas, flexible for electricity, while for July-December 2024 they appear to be £680.
16°C degree days for July-Dec 2023 is 827, while for same period 2024 is 846.
So not a huge difference over thoise 6 month periods.
Subjectively the upper floors of the house are warmer, while the ground floor is cooler. The ground floor is less well insulated than it was in 2023, and draughtier (improved underfloor ventilation, all ground floor coverings removed, and parts of boarding also removed), and I’m confident that things can only get better when the insulation and airtightness issues are resolved and implemented.
Finally I managed to sell the combi boiler (only 7 years old) to someone who needed one to see him and his family through the winter while renovating a property before installing a heat pump!
3 Likes