Tado vrs ASHP

I’d be inclined to push back fairly hard on those heat loss calculations, if they result in a much larger ASHP than you really need.

  • There are countless tales of woe on this forum about oversized HPs and the consequent poor efficiencies due to excessive cycling. Many users have ended up negotiating a replacement smaller unit with their installers as a result.
  • Unless your house is very large and/or very poorly insulated (or you live on top of Bodmin Moor :wink:), I’d be surprised if you actually need more than about 8kW. The MCS “rules” for calculating heat loss (and thus qualifying for the all-important BUS grant) are - or at least were (I believe that they are currently under review) - based on pessimistic ventilation flows. If you (or your installer) can demonstrate a lower ventilation component, you may end up with a HP better matched to your real requirement.
  • The only downside of a well-matched HP size (to max heat loss) is the potential restriction on setback (see House Thermal Inertia and Roomstat Setback (some cautionary notes)).