"useless" defrost after Ecodan R32 4kW startup?

During mild weather (5-10C), my heat pump will systematically defrost after startup, even if it’s not a defrost weather (mild temp, low humidity). Here is an illustrative example from this morning:

Red/blue=flow/return, yellow=ecodan external temp (th7), green=true external temp, purple=liquid pipe temp (TH3)

There are several questionable elements :

  • Before startup TH3 nicely tracks the true external temp (≈4.3C), while th7 is off (≈5.9C).
  • TH3 immediately shoots down to negative temperatures, then goes up again.
  • The ecodan does not seem to care that TH3 is back in normal range (sometimes TH3 will be back > 0), it triggers the defrost after 40-60 minutes.

To be clear: this happens even if it’s 8C or 9C, basically what seems to matter is that TH3 is negative right at startup (sometimes around -1C to -2C). The defrost lasts seconds (no actual ice on the unit) and there is no defrost after that.

Have you seen this in your systems? Is there an issue with the heat pump that causes TH3 to go down too much? Is the issue caused by the overestimation of th7, since defrost seems to be triggered by the difference th7-th3?

Thanks!

Hi Stephan,

Welcome to the forum :slight_smile:

I’ve not seen anything like this happening elsewhere, so it does seem to be an anomoly.

Perhaps @johncantor has some insight here?

Hi Tim,

Thanks for your answer! I tried looking up posts across different forums but did not find similar examples. Here is today’s defrost, which is quite extreme, so maybe a good complement to troubleshoot what’s going on:

I added the compressor discharge in pink. It’s a bit harder to read, but at startup the temperature was 7C (10C according to th7), TH3 shot down to -6C. Here are compressor frequencies:

In this example, the defrost threshold is reached even with true outside temp (13K difference), so I’m starting to think there may be an issue with refrigerant levels or refrigerant circulation…

I notice my R32 6kw did a defrost in mild weather shortly after startup. I will have a look over the weekend.

Thanks John, I’m curious to see you observe a similar pattern. I took a closer look at examples of good vs bad startups and found an example where things worked out well at just below 10C:

(Yellow=Th4, red/pink/purple=flow/setpoint/return, green=ambient, blue=TH3)

A striking difference is the behavior of the lev:

It closes down progressively, the system takes some time to build superheat. In all examples shown before, the lev goes in the 240 position very quickly, which may be causing a starvation on the TH3 side?

not really had time to think about your graphs, however, i did find this on mine on 31st Oct. An unexpected and unnecessary defrost after start. There is no way it was frosted at start because it had been warmer than 6c out. Given my Carnot COP is often 55%, i’m sure the refrigerant charge is OK. The defrost seems to be a glitch of some kinds… dont know. Another on very early morning on 20thOct. Just looked at the other two 6kW on HPM, and cannot see any similar defrost behavour.

Interesting, there seems to be a characteristic dip at the beginning of the cycle for “failed” startups. It’s not super visible on my curves but it’s there. What’s funny is that it’s not related to compressor speed in my case, that’s why I suspect it’s the LEV suddenly closing. Judging by the energy input being stable in your example it’s likely the same issue.

I’m trying to find a way to side step this issue, I’ll run some tests tomorrow morning. Out of curiosity: are you using auto adaptation?

I did some experimenting on Sunday but could not find a way to avoid the startup defrost. However, it seems like the LEV is systematically closing at the 5 min mark after a fresh startup. If the compressor stays at high frequency at this point, I see this characteristic dip in the flow temperature, coupled with very low TH3 and high superheat. This can cause frosting conditions up to 8-9C. The frost would not form or melt immediately if temperatures are this high, but the defrost conditions are triggered. The defrost itself is actually quite harmless, as there is no ice to melt and the heat is recovered afterwards (COP is higher than usual for 5-10 minutes).

I see 3 potential solutions to this “problem”: a) try to trigger a soft start, forcing the compressor to go to low modulation before the 5min mark (similar to eco mode in DHW), b) switch to auto adapt and see if it can learn to soft start (I read somewhere that it improves defrosting and noticed that compressor startup is not the same as fixed flow), c) change the flow rate of the system (not very practical, but I’m curious if it has an impact).

I’ll keep experimenting and posting here for anyone curious or noticing the same issue.